SYDNEY, Australia / MENA Newswire / – The New South Wales government has shelved new underquoting rules, warning they could hurt buyers and sellers in the current housing downturn. The rules had been set to begin on Tuesday. Premier Chris Minns made a last-minute intervention, and the ABC reported the changes will be paused for up to a year. By Monday evening, Minns had decided the reform should not proceed. The decision came only hours before the rules were due to take effect.

Minns had raised concerns on Monday morning that agents would be barred from cutting an advertised price, even when a property drew no interest. He said it was not the seller’s or the agent’s fault if prices were dropping. The premier said the laws had effectively assumed that property values would keep rising. Minns said agents in his own electorate of Kogarah had given negative feedback about the changes. He described the consequences as unforeseen but something the government must address.
Underquoting is the practice of advertising a property below the price an agent expects it to fetch. It can attract interest but frustrates buyers, and it is already banned in NSW. The next stage of the Labor government’s reforms would have stopped agents advertising a price below a written offer that the seller had rejected. The Real Estate Institute of NSW had opposed the change. The rule aimed to stop agents listing prices sellers would not accept.
Falling prices expose a flaw
Conditions have shifted since the laws were passed. Cotality data reported by the ABC shows Sydney house prices have dropped close to 9.7% since the end of January, while units have fallen 5.2%. The slide comes amid a broader Australian housing downturn. Under the paused rule, a seller expecting $1.5 million who turned down a $1.3 million written offer could not see the home advertised below $1.3 million.
The advertised price could not be lowered even if the seller later accepted that their expectations were too high. Institute chief executive Tim McKibbin said buyers would not learn that a home had become more affordable. He said the rule misled buyers and disadvantaged vendors. McKibbin said agents had warned the government the laws would not work in the market. Minns said a seller who rejected an offer might accept it a month later, especially in a falling market or distressed sale.
Government turns to regulation
Parliament has only a few sitting days left this year, so the government is not expected to change the legislation. It is instead expected to make a regulation that has the same effect. The requirement for agents to publish a selling price or price range will also be paused. Penalties of up to $110,000 for underquoting will be delayed as the government reviews the full package. The backflip is a blow to Fair Trading Minister Anoulack Chanthivong.
Chanthivong is also fighting a separate preselection contest for his Macquarie Fields seat. He said the laws were passed at a different time and in a different economic and housing market. Chanthivong said many people were already doing it tough and the government did not want the rules to make buying a home harder. Shadow Fair Trading Minister Tim James said the government should have designed laws able to withstand a downturn. James said property prices move in cycles.
